هل Smile Train مؤسسة خيرية موثوقة؟
مستقل charity trust assessment · Updated April 26, 2026
48
Donor Caution Advised
Significant transparency concerns — conduct thorough research before donating
D
Smile Train is a nonprofit organization بدرجة ثقة Nerq تبلغ 48.2/100 (D). Donor recommendation: Proceed with Caution. Cleft surgery funding worldwide. 1.5M+ surgeries funded. Sustainable model.
Overall assessment: Smile Train is not موصى به لـ donors without further due diligence.
تفاصيل درجة الثقة
Financial الشفافية (30%)65/100 Program Effectiveness (25%)49/100 Accountability (10%)59/100
النتائج الرئيسية
⚠Financial الشفافية: 65/100 — Good
⚠Program Effectiveness: 49/100 — Fair
⚠Governance: 44/100 — Fair
⚠Donor Trust: 49/100 — Fair
⚠Accountability: 59/100 — Fair
How does Smile Train spend its money?
Financial الشفافية score: 65/100 (Good).
Estimated program expense ratio: 52%.
A significant portion of funds may go to administration and fundraising.
Financial estimates derived from Nerq analysis. Verify with the charity's public filings (IRS Form 990) for exact figures.
How is Smile Train governed?
Governance score: 44/100 (Fair).
Accountability score: 59/100 (Fair).
Governance practices raise concerns — donors should verify board independence and audit history.
Accountability measures are present but could be strengthened.
الأسئلة الشائعة
Is Smile Train a trustworthy charity?
Smile Train لديه درجة ثقة Nerq تبلغ 48.2/100 (D). Proceed with Caution. Conduct thorough research before donating.
How does Smile Train spend donations?
Estimated program expense ratio: 52%. Financial الشفافية score: 65/100. Review the latest Form 990 for detailed spending breakdown.
Is my donation to Smile Train tax-deductible?
Check Smile Train's IRS tax-exempt status on the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search tool. Most registered 501(c)(3) nonprofits offer tax-deductible donations. Verify directly with the organization.
Does Smile Train publish annual reports?
الشفافية score: 65/100. Check the organization website or GuideStar/Candid for available reports.
How effective is Smile Train at achieving its mission?
Program Effectiveness score: 49/100 (Fair). Limited evidence of program effectiveness — request impact data directly.
Who oversees Smile Train?
Governance score: 44/100. Governance information is limited — review IRS Form 990 for board details.
How does Smile Train compare to similar charities?
Smile Train has an overall trust score of 48.2/100. Compare with similar nonprofits below or browse the full charity index to find top-rated organizations in the same cause area.
كيف حسبنا هذه الدرجة
Smile Train's trust score of 48.2/100 (D) is بناءً على analysis of public financial filings, governance disclosures, program outcomes, and donor feedback signals. The score reflects 5 charity-specific أبعاد: Financial الشفافية (65/100, 30%), Program Effectiveness (49/100, 25%), Governance (44/100, 20%), Donor Trust (49/100, 15%), and Accountability (59/100, 10%).
Nerq indexes over 7.5 million entities across 26 registries, enabling direct cross-organization comparison. Scores are updated as new data becomes available.
Full methodology documentation · قراءة آلية data (JSON API)
آخر تحديث: April 26, 2026 · Data sources: IRS Form 990, GuideStar, Charity Navigator, public filings