mcp-server vs toolhive — Trust Score Comparison

Name: mcp-server vs toolhive Trust Comparison
Creator: Nerq

Side-by-side trust comparison of mcp-server and toolhive. Scores based on security, compliance, maintenance, popularity, and ecosystem signals.

mcp-server scores 65.5/100 (E) while toolhive scores 0.0/100 (A) on the Nerq Trust Score. mcp-server leads by 65.5 points. mcp-server is a uncategorized tool with 0 stars. toolhive is a infrastructure tool with 1,610 stars.

mcp-server

65.5

Categoryuncategorized

Stars0

Sourcemcp_registry

toolhive

0.0

Categoryinfrastructure

Stars1,610

Sourcegithub

Security1

Compliance85

Maintenance1

Documentation1

Detailed Metric Comparison

Metric	mcp-server	toolhive
Trust Score	65.5/100	0.0/100
Grade	E	A
Stars	0	1,610
Category	uncategorized	infrastructure
Security	N/A	1
Compliance	N/A	85
Maintenance	N/A	1
Documentation	N/A	1
EU AI Act Risk	N/A	N/A
Verified	No	No

Verdict

mcp-server leads with a trust score of 65.5/100 compared to toolhive's 0.0/100 (a 65.5-point difference). However, toolhive has stronger community adoption (1,610 vs 0 stars). Both agents should be evaluated based on your specific requirements.

Detailed Analysis

Security

Security scores measure dependency vulnerabilities, CVE exposure, and security practices. mcp-server scores N/A and toolhive scores 1 on this dimension.

Maintenance & Activity

Activity scores reflect how actively each project is maintained. mcp-server: N/A, toolhive: 1.

Documentation

Documentation quality is evaluated based on README, API docs, and example coverage. mcp-server: N/A, toolhive: 1.

Community & Adoption

mcp-server has 0 GitHub stars while toolhive has 1,610. toolhive has significantly broader community adoption, which typically means more Stack Overflow answers, more third-party tutorials, and faster ecosystem development.

When to Choose Each Tool

Choose mcp-server if you need:

Higher overall trust score — more reliable for production use

Choose toolhive if you need:

Stronger security profile with fewer known vulnerabilities
More actively maintained with faster release cadence
Larger community (1,610 vs 0 stars)
Better documentation for faster onboarding

Switching from mcp-server to toolhive (or vice versa)

When migrating between mcp-server and toolhive, consider these factors:

API Compatibility: mcp-server (uncategorized) and toolhive (infrastructure) serve different categories, so migration may require significant refactoring.
Security Review: Run a security audit after migration. Check the mcp-server safety report and toolhive safety report for known issues.
Testing: Ensure your test suite covers all integration points before switching in production.
Community Support: mcp-server has 0 stars and toolhive has 1,610. Larger communities typically mean better Stack Overflow answers and migration guides.

mcp-server Safety Report toolhive Safety Report mcp-server Alternatives toolhive Alternatives

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is safer, mcp-server or toolhive?

Based on Nerq's independent trust assessment, mcp-server has a trust score of 65.5/100 (E) while toolhive scores 0.0/100 (A). The 65.5-point difference suggests mcp-server has a stronger trust profile. Trust scores are based on security, compliance, maintenance, documentation, and community adoption.

How do mcp-server and toolhive compare on security?

mcp-server has a security score of N/A/100 and toolhive scores 1/100. There is a notable difference in their security assessments. mcp-server's compliance score is N/A/100 (EU risk: N/A), while toolhive's is 85/100 (EU risk: N/A).

Should I use mcp-server or toolhive?

The choice depends on your requirements. mcp-server (uncategorized, 0 stars) and toolhive (infrastructure, 1,610 stars) serve different use cases. On trust, mcp-server scores 65.5/100 and toolhive scores 0.0/100. Review the full KYA reports for each agent before making a decision. Consider factors like integration requirements, documentation quality (N/A vs 1), and maintenance activity (N/A vs 1).

Related Comparisons

Last updated: 2026-11-14 | Data refreshed weekly
Disclaimer: Nerq trust scores are automated assessments based on publicly available signals. They are not endorsements or guarantees. Always conduct your own due diligence.