toolhive vs xmcp — Trust Score Comparison

Name: toolhive vs xmcp Trust Comparison
Creator: Nerq

Side-by-side trust comparison of toolhive and xmcp. Scores based on security, compliance, maintenance, popularity, and ecosystem signals.

toolhive scores 0.0/100 (A) while xmcp scores 0.0/100 (C) on the Nerq Trust Score. The two agents are essentially tied on overall trust. toolhive is a infrastructure tool with 1,610 stars. xmcp is a uncategorized tool with 0 stars.

toolhive

0.0

Categoryinfrastructure

Stars1,610

Sourcegithub

Security1

Compliance85

Maintenance1

Documentation1

xmcp

0.0

Categoryuncategorized

Stars0

Sourcenpm_full

Compliance100

Detailed Metric Comparison

Metric	toolhive	xmcp
Trust Score	0.0/100	0.0/100
Grade	A	C
Stars	1,610	0
Category	infrastructure	uncategorized
Security	1	N/A
Compliance	85	100
Maintenance	1	N/A
Documentation	1	N/A
EU AI Act Risk	N/A	N/A
Verified	No	No

Verdict

toolhive (0.0) and xmcp (0.0) have nearly identical trust scores. Both are solid choices. The decision should come down to your specific use case, team preferences, and integration requirements rather than trust differences.

Detailed Analysis

Security

Security scores measure dependency vulnerabilities, CVE exposure, and security practices. toolhive scores 1 and xmcp scores N/A on this dimension.

Maintenance & Activity

Activity scores reflect how actively each project is maintained. toolhive: 1, xmcp: N/A.

Documentation

Documentation quality is evaluated based on README, API docs, and example coverage. toolhive: 1, xmcp: N/A.

Community & Adoption

toolhive has 1,610 GitHub stars while xmcp has 0. toolhive has significantly broader community adoption, which typically means more Stack Overflow answers, more third-party tutorials, and faster ecosystem development.

When to Choose Each Tool

Choose toolhive if you need:

Stronger security profile with fewer known vulnerabilities
More actively maintained with faster release cadence
Larger community (1,610 vs 0 stars)
Better documentation for faster onboarding

Choose xmcp if you need:

Consider if it better fits your specific use case

Switching from toolhive to xmcp (or vice versa)

When migrating between toolhive and xmcp, consider these factors:

API Compatibility: toolhive (infrastructure) and xmcp (uncategorized) serve different categories, so migration may require significant refactoring.
Security Review: Run a security audit after migration. Check the toolhive safety report and xmcp safety report for known issues.
Testing: Ensure your test suite covers all integration points before switching in production.
Community Support: toolhive has 1,610 stars and xmcp has 0. Larger communities typically mean better Stack Overflow answers and migration guides.

toolhive Safety Report xmcp Safety Report toolhive Alternatives xmcp Alternatives

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is safer, toolhive or xmcp?

Based on Nerq's independent trust assessment, toolhive has a trust score of 0.0/100 (A) while xmcp scores 0.0/100 (C). Both agents are very close in overall trust. Trust scores are based on security, compliance, maintenance, documentation, and community adoption.

How do toolhive and xmcp compare on security?

toolhive has a security score of 1/100 and xmcp scores N/A/100. There is a notable difference in their security assessments. toolhive's compliance score is 85/100 (EU risk: N/A), while xmcp's is 100/100 (EU risk: N/A).

Should I use toolhive or xmcp?

The choice depends on your requirements. toolhive (infrastructure, 1,610 stars) and xmcp (uncategorized, 0 stars) serve different use cases. On trust, toolhive scores 0.0/100 and xmcp scores 0.0/100. Review the full KYA reports for each agent before making a decision. Consider factors like integration requirements, documentation quality (1 vs N/A), and maintenance activity (1 vs N/A).

Related Comparisons

Last updated: 2026-10-31 | Data refreshed weekly
Disclaimer: Nerq trust scores are automated assessments based on publicly available signals. They are not endorsements or guarantees. Always conduct your own due diligence.